Delete delete deleeeeeeeete

Mario’s bike – Henri Cartier-Bresson

Something that’s been around a while and blogged about by plenty of others but all the same…

Digital Blue says:

When everything is blurred you cannot convey the motion of the bicyclist. On the other hand, if the bicyclist is not the subject– what was?

-voted as “deleteme” (from the Delete me! group)

Gianni D. Pro User says:

I like very much this picture. I like the atmosphere, the movement and the perspective.

voted as “saveme” (from the Delete me! group)

beyond the pale says:

hard to tell at this size but is everything meant to be moving in this shot, all seems blurred

-voted as “deleteme2” (from the Delete me! group)

Agata… says:

Why is the staircase so “soft”? Camera shake? Like the angle though.

Agata… says:

-voted as “deleteme3” (from the Delete me! group)

dalbergaria says:

THATS SOOOOOO FUNNNNY!!!!!!!

How can you guys talk about photography if YOU NO NOTHING ABOUT IT!?!?!?

DCP, Infinite_vest, AgataL, you have NO idea how stupid you look now!

Thats F*#&#^%ing awesome!

carolyn_in_oregon Pro User says:

so small

so blurry

to better show a sense of movement SOMETHING has to be in sharp focus

-voted as “deleteme4” (from the Delete me! group)

carolyn_in_oregon Pro User says:

@dalbergaria

I think you’re funny

hahahahahahahha

leolecal says:

our master is “shaking in the grave”.

so shame on you ‘deleteme ppl’..

dalbergaria says:

Deleteme pepole… YOU GUYS ARE NUTS!!! PLEASE! Stop that…

“to better show a sense of movement SOMETHING has to be in sharp focus” WHO TOLD YOU THAT CAROL???

Someone should write a book about this… Its unbelievable…

– voted as DELETE the Deleteme people! ahahah

carolyn_in_oregon Pro User says:

please don’t post to this pool if you can’t deal with criticism

read the front page of this pool
duh

dalbergaria says:

I can deal with criticism…

But can’t I criticise STUPID criticism?

Now you are not dealing very well with my criticism… I guess.

beyond the pale says:

oh, hang on now I get it, it’s not a problem with the shot, it’s our opinions which are lacking, this photo is of such an intrinsically high quality that there could be no other explanation.
Dalbegaria – you seem very attached to this photo or poster, but when it is submitted to a public group for criticism, then, well you get what you pay for. None of us claims to be an expert but our opinions are valid here, feel free to post a comment detailing why you like this shot…

wilkiecoco Pro User says:

Nicely composed, but blurry

-voted as “deleteme5” (from the Delete me! group)

CarlosBravo Pro User says:

This photo is pure art.

-voted as “saveme3” (from the Delete me! group)

dalbergaria says:

infinite: Patient you need to be. And the force with you will be!

hahahah

Gary Lindquist Pro User says:

This looks contrived, which is not a bad thing. If this is a planned shot, it just didn’t come out right. If you can round up Mario, I would do it again. This time put the camera on a tripod and use the smallest aperture possible to get the best DoF. What I would hope for is that the railings are sharp and that mario on the bike shows a blur. Must have the foreground sharp, though. Without that, the image will never fly.

-voted as “deleteme6” (from Deleteme! group)

Bukutgirl Pro User says:

yeah and?

grey, blurry, small, odd crop

-voted as “deleteme7

sparty lea Pro User says:

I very much like the crop and all the wierd angles in this, the patchwork of textures in the street is great, I like the grey grainey look it has but I’d like to see it much bigger
Cant vote on this size

davidchardman Pro User says:

Ha Ha, very funny 😉

paddysat Pro User says:

Nice form, AR. You have fished out all the reasons I dont come around hyeres any more.

How could I not save this!?!

I claim masterpiece!

-voted as “saveme4” (from the Delete me! group)

okrahoma says:

a lot of winking going on here… was this shot by another André?

dElay says:

perfect !

dalbergaria says:

Poddysat got the point!

Good job man!

😉

Lets go… No balls for the deleteme9 and 10?

😀

André Rabelo says:

Im almost crying. My poor digital photography, adjusted with photoshop is deceiving…

Nobody loves me…

jam-L  Pro User  says:

great catch!

MiniTar says:

Ok, I’m not a photography expert.
Ok, I’m very into lomography.
Ok, I’m very very fan of colors.

But I just can’t delete this photo, cause I can see the beauty of an unsharp shot, the movement of it and I’m able to rebuilt this momment in my head.

So, just like paddysat said:

I claim masterpiece!

My whish is to save this photo, but I wont.
I want that you guys delete it, cause it will just prove my theory: you guys know nothing about good photoshography, you just care for very regular photos. you are nuts and patethics!

PS. Besides, I know a little bit of the history of photography 🙂

igilmour Pro User says:

bit too blurred to be worth a save from me

-voted as “deleteme10” (from the Delete me! group)

dvcz Pro User says:

Banditrouxas!

felmagalhães Pro User says:

LOL
this is the day deleteme has entered the history of photography as the worst (not in terms of being mean, but in terms of being mis-informed, mis-educated, un-cultured, and all other things that can be summarized by the word STUPID) critics this art form has ever seen. you guys have just proved that all your votes aren’t worth the least of all considerations. thinking that deleteme criticism will improve the way we photograph is BULLSHIT. it’ll just turn us into advertising/stock photographer wannabes, gadget show-offs that only care for the technicalities. you guys are full of yourselves (in other words, full of shit!).
Posted 31 months ago. ( permalink )

Mario’s bike – André Rabelo’s photostream on Flickr and the original post

f/1.0 – The Dark Side of photsharing sites

8 Comments

  1. Saw this photo (with a few hundred others) at the HCb exhibition in Bradford last month. It is very small, although why anyone would be unable to form an opinion about it solely because of its size, I have really no idea.

    I stood and wondered what HCB was trying to do here, and several of us speculated how many times the cyclist was asked to scoot down that alley before the photo was taken. The exhibition was really interesting in that it showed all the shots from a particular series, often with only very slight changes in composition.

    Some of the photographs were really quite lovely by today’s standards. Most weren’t, and this one is one that really has no particular merit, within today’s aesthetic, at least. It does look like an accidental snapshot.

    HCB’s reputation is well deserved though. The sheer number of naturalistic ‘street’ photographs he produced is astonising, and the portraits are memorable. But I’m not at all surprised that this one wasn’t well received by the crit group. It’s a refreshingly honest assessment, and one that might well be made of many um, great masters of the past. Yosemite valley with clouds, anyone? 😉

  2. Hello B. The decisive moment is in the thread. That’s what struck me. Concerning merit though, is agreement a helpful measure of greatness?

  3. “If this is a planned shot, it just didn’t come out right.”

    Thanks for reminding me of that one Alex. One of the best ever threads on Flickr.

  4. Brendadada’s use of the phrase “by today’s standards” resonated with me.

    Roger Hicks wrote recently in AP that Flickr’s Explore is influencing perceptions of what good photography is. Not much on Explore is straight out of rangefinder, of course.

    That this image is an object lesson in composition ought to be obvious, at the very least.

  5. so this is still running around after all these years – sort of surprised but I guess I shouldn’t be.

    I’ve thought about this day a few times since – and what it comes down to is just because a name is attached to something – doesn’t mean it’s inherently great or should be given a less stringent review than other work – for me this keeps me on my toes and keeps pushing me.

  6. @ Garry – Cheers mate.

    @ Phil – Spot on as ever.

    @ bukutgirl – Great you found this. Thanks for commenting. You helped make some internet history here. Go you!!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.